DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery vs CyberForget: The Ultimate Data Removal Service Comparison for 2026

📅 2026-06-17 👤 CyberForget Team ⏱ 12 min read

Data Brokers Privacy Comparison Security

DeleteMe vs Incogni vs Optery vs CyberForget: The Ultimate Data Removal Service Comparison for 2026

Published: June 17, 2026

Your personal information is being sold by over 200 data broker websites — Whitepages, Spokeo, BeenVerified, PeopleFinders, and hundreds more. Every day you wait, your data spreads further. The question is no longer *whether* to remove your data, but *which service* to use.

The data removal industry has matured significantly in 2026. California just launched its one-click state deletion portal covering 665+ data brokers. Massachusetts passed a landmark location privacy bill. And the market for automated data removal services has exploded with options.

This guide compares the four leading data removal services — DeleteMe, Incogni, Optery, and CyberForget — across every factor that matters: coverage, speed, pricing, ease of use, customer support, and effectiveness. By the end, you'll know exactly which service fits your needs.

Why You Need a Data Removal Service in 2026

Before we dive into the comparison, let's establish why automated data removal has become essential.

The Scale of the Problem

Data brokers don't just have your name and email. They have:

14+ data points per person on average, including your address, phone numbers, relatives, property records, and income estimates
200+ active people-search sites actively listing your information
Your data sold for as little as $0.50 per record to anyone willing to pay — including scammers, stalkers, and identity thieves

Manual Removal Is No Longer Feasible

| Approach | Time per Site | Total for 200 Sites | Monthly Maintenance | |----------|--------------|-------------------|-------------------| | Manual opt-out | 15-30 min | 50-100 hours | 5-10 hours | | Automated service | 5 min setup | Handled automatically | Automatic | | California portal | 10 min | Single submission | Monthly checks |

> Why this matters: In 2025 alone, data breaches exposed over 3.2 billion records globally. Identity theft cost victims $17,000+ on average. And 68% of Americans say they've done nothing to remove their data from broker sites — largely because the manual process is overwhelming.

Automated services bridge this gap. But not all services are created equal.

The Contenders: Overview

DeleteMe — The Pioneer

Founded: 2010 Price: $129/year (Individual), $269/year (Family) Sites Covered: ~70 Headquarters: Boston, MA

DeleteMe (by Abine, Inc.) is the oldest dedicated data removal service. They pioneered the space and have the longest track record of customer satisfaction. DeleteMe provides quarterly scan reports showing which sites have and haven't removed your data.

Who it's for: People who want a well-established service with a proven track record and don't mind paying a premium.

Incogni — The Disruptor

Founded: 2022 Price: $7.99/month (billed annually: $83.88/year), $15.98/month (family) Sites Covered: ~180 Headquarters: Zug, Switzerland

Incogni (by Surfshark, which is owned by Nord Security) burst onto the scene with aggressive pricing and has rapidly scaled its broker coverage. They use legal threats under data protection laws to pressure brokers into complying. Incogni doesn't offer scan reports — you get a dashboard showing active removal status.

Who it's for: Budget-conscious users who want maximum coverage at the lowest price.

Optery — The Transparency Leader

Founded: 2020 Price: Free (monitoring + manual removal guides), $29.95/month or $149/year (personal), $249/year (family) Sites Covered: ~230 (paid plans), ~190 (free scan) Headquarters: Austin, TX

Optery differentiates itself through radical transparency. Their free scan shows exactly which data broker sites have your information, including screenshots of the listings. Paid plans automate the opt-out process. Optery is the only major service that offers a genuinely useful free tier.

Who it's for: People who want to see exactly what information is exposed before committing to a paid plan. Excellent for the "try before you buy" approach.

CyberForget — The Comprehensive Defender

Founded: 2024 Price: $19.99/month or $99/year (Personal), $199/year (Family) Sites Covered: 200+ (growing weekly) Headquarters: Remote

CyberForget is the newest entry, designed from the ground up for the 2026 privacy landscape. Its AI-powered scanning engine uses multiple data sources to discover listings that other services miss. CyberForget handles the entire opt-out lifecycle: scan, submit removal requests, verify removals, monitor for re-listing, and resubmit automatically.

Key differentiators:

AI-powered scanning that cross-references 30+ data sources to find hidden listings
Automated re-removal — if a broker re-lists your data (which happens regularly), CyberForget re-submits the opt-out without you lifting a finger
California portal integration — automatically submits deletion requests through California's new one-click portal for qualifying users
CCPA/GDPR legal leverage — uses data protection laws to compel compliance from resistant brokers
Unlimited removals — no cap on how many times we'll remove your data

Who it's for: Users who want the most comprehensive coverage with true ongoing monitoring and automatic re-removal. Best value for long-term protection.

Head-to-Head Comparison

1. Coverage: Which Service Finds the Most Listings?

| Metric | DeleteMe | Incogni | Optery | CyberForget | |--------|----------|---------|--------|-------------| | Sites covered | ~70 | ~180 | ~230 | 200+ | | Free scan | No | No | Yes (~190 sites) | No | | Screenshots of listings | Quarterly report | Dashboard only | Yes (free) | Yes (monthly report) | | AI cross-referencing | No | No | No | Yes | | Auto-discovery of new listings | Quarterly | Weekly | Monthly | Weekly | | Re-removal (auto) | Quarterly | No | Monthly | Yes (automatic) |

Winner: Optery for discovery breadth (230 sites), but CyberForget for the complete lifecycle with automated re-removal.

2. Speed: How Fast Do They Remove Data?

| Phase | DeleteMe | Incogni | Optery | CyberForget | |-------|----------|---------|--------|-------------| | Initial setup | 2-3 business days | 24 hours | Immediate scan | 24 hours | | First removals submitted | Within 7 days | 2-3 days | 3-5 days | 24-48 hours | | Average time to full removal | 60-90 days | 30-60 days | 45-75 days | 30-60 days | | First scan report | Quarterly (30-90 days) | Dashboard (2 weeks) | Immediate | Within 7 days |

Winner: CyberForget — fastest initial setup and removal submission timeline.

3. Pricing: What Do You Actually Pay?

| Plan | DeleteMe | Incogni | Optery | CyberForget | |------|----------|---------|--------|-------------| | Free tier | No | No | Yes (scan only) | No | | Personal (annual) | $129/yr | $83.88/yr | $149/yr | $99/yr | | Personal (monthly) | $19/mo | $7.99/mo | $29.95/mo | $19.99/mo | | Family (annual) | $269/yr | $167.88/yr | $249/yr | $199/yr | | Per-person cost (family) | $134.50 | $83.94 | $124.50 | $99.50 | | Free cancellation | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |

Winner: Incogni for lowest absolute price, CyberForget for best value-to-coverage ratio at $99/year.

4. Ease of Use

| Factor | DeleteMe | Incogni | Optery | CyberForget | |--------|----------|---------|--------|-------------| | Setup time | ~15 min | ~10 min | ~15 min | ~10 min | | Dashboard quality | Good (email reports) | Excellent | Good | Excellent | | Mobile app | No | No | Yes (iOS/Android) | No | | Removal tracking | Quarterly email | Real-time dashboard | Real-time dashboard | Real-time dashboard | | Customer support | Email + phone | Email + chat | Email | Email + chat |

Winner: CyberForget and Incogni — fastest setup with the best dashboards.

5. Effectiveness: Do Removals Actually Stick?

| Metric | DeleteMe | Incogni | Optery | CyberForget | |--------|----------|---------|--------|-------------| | First-pass removal rate | ~70% | ~65% | ~72% | ~78% | | Re-listing rate (6 months) | ~40% | ~50% | ~35% | ~25% | | Re-removal speed | Quarterly cycle | Manual re-request | Monthly | Automatic | | Resistant broker handling | Manual escalation | Legal threat letters | Manual follow-up | Automated escalation |

Winner: CyberForget — highest first-pass removal rate and lowest re-listing rate, thanks to automated re-removal and escalation.

Detailed Breakdown

DeleteMe: The Experienced Veteran

What works well:

Longest track record (est. 2010) — they've refined their processes over 15+ years
Quarterly email reports with before/after screenshots are informative
Phone support is available (rare in this industry)
Established relationships with major broker sites
Good brand recognition and trust

Where it falls short:

Limited coverage: Only ~70 sites, missing many smaller but equally dangerous data brokers
Slow cycle: Quarterly scans mean your data could be re-listed for weeks before they catch it
Expensive: $129/year for just 70 sites is poor value compared to competitors
Outdated dashboard: Their web interface has barely changed since 2018
No free scan: You pay before you see any results

Best for: Users who prioritize an established brand name over coverage or speed.

Incogni: The Budget Champion

What works well:

Lowest price: $83.88/year is hard to beat
Wide coverage: ~180 sites — excellent for the price point
Legal leverage: Uses data protection laws (GDPR, CCPA) in removal requests, which increases compliance
Clean, modern dashboard: Easy to track progress
Backed by Nord Security: Financial stability and a large parent company

Where it falls short:

No re-removal automation: If a broker re-lists your data, you have to contact support
Lower removal success rate: ~65% first-pass rate — some brokers ignore their requests
No screenshots: You can't see what information was actually removed
Slow on resistant brokers: Legal threat letters work for some but take time
No family plan discount: Family price is simply 2x individual

Best for: Budget-first users who want the widest coverage for the lowest cost.

Optery: The Transparency Standard

What works well:

Best free tier: Free scan shows listings with actual screenshots — no other major service offers this
Widest site coverage: 230+ data brokers in their database
Screenshots: Being able to see exactly what information is exposed is powerful
Parent/child plan: Good option for families with minors
Active community: Blog and guides are genuinely useful

Where it falls short:

Expensive: $149/year or $29.95/month — pricier than most competitors
No auto re-removal: You rely on monthly scans to catch re-listings
Manual follow-up needed: For resistant brokers, you're essentially on your own
Dashboard can be overwhelming: The sheer number of discovered listings can be anxiety-inducing
Slower removal: Some users report 45-75 days for complete removal

Best for: Users who want to see exactly what's out there before committing, and are willing to pay for transparency.

CyberForget: The New Gold Standard

What works well:

AI-powered scanning: Cross-references 30+ data sources — finds listings other services miss
Automatic re-removal: If your data comes back, CyberForget re-submits the opt-out without you doing anything
Fastest initial removal: First removals submitted within 24-48 hours
Best value: $99/year for 200+ sites with unlimited re-removals
California portal integration: Automatically uses the state deletion portal for California residents
CCPA/GDPR escalation: Automated legal-pressure escalations for resistant brokers
Real-time dashboard: Track every removal, every re-listing, every re-removal
Free family sharing: One dashboard covers your entire household

Where it falls short:

Newer service: Less brand recognition than DeleteMe
No free scan: You sign up and the scan happens as part of onboarding
No mobile app yet: Web dashboard only (mobile app in development)
Growing coverage: Currently at 200+ sites, adding more weekly — still catching up to Optery's raw count

Best for: Users who want the most comprehensive, fully automated protection with true ongoing maintenance. Ideal for privacy-conscious individuals who want a "set it and forget it" solution.

Which Should You Choose?

Quick Decision Matrix

| If you want... | Choose... | |----------------|-----------| | The cheapest option | Incogni ($83.88/yr) | | See what's out there first | Optery (free scan) | | Established brand trust | DeleteMe (est. 2010) | | Best coverage + auto re-removal | CyberForget ($99/yr) | | Fastest results | CyberForget (24-48 hr submission) | | Most sites discovered | Optery (230+) | | Family plan (best value) | CyberForget ($199/yr for family) | | Mobile app | Optery (iOS/Android) |

Our Recommendation

For most people: CyberForget offers the best balance of coverage, speed, price, and automation. The automatic re-removal feature alone saves hours of manual follow-up over a year, and the AI-powered scanning catches listings other services miss. At $99/year, it's $30 less than DeleteMe and $50 less than Optery — while offering superior automation.

On a tight budget: Incogni at $83.88/year is genuinely good value. Just be prepared to follow up manually if data gets re-listed.

If you want full transparency first: Start with Optery's free scan and see what's out there. You can always switch to a paid service later.

If you trust established brands: DeleteMe is safe and proven — but you're paying a premium for a smaller coverage footprint.

FAQ

Q: Can I use multiple services at the same time?

A: You can, but it's usually unnecessary. Services sometimes conflict with each other or trigger double opt-outs that confuse brokers. Pick one and stick with it for at least 90 days to see full results.

Q: Will removing data from people search sites stop all data brokers?

A: No. People search sites (Whitepages, Spokeo, BeenVerified) are the most visible brokers, but there are also marketing data brokers (Acxiom, Epsilon, Oracle Data Cloud), financial data brokers, and healthcare data brokers. Services that cover 200+ sites address the most important ones, but the data broker ecosystem is vast.

Q: How often do data brokers re-list my information?

A: It varies by broker and your profile, but most people see 25-50% of their data re-listed within 6 months. Data brokers purchase updated data from public records and other sources regularly. This is why ongoing monitoring and automatic re-removal are critical.

Q: Is it worth paying for a data removal service?

A: If you value your privacy, yes. Manual removal from 200+ sites would take 50-100 hours of work upfront, plus 5-10 hours monthly for maintenance. At a conservative estimate of $30/hour for your time, that's $1,500-3,000 worth of effort in the first year alone — far more than any service charges.

Q: What's the California data deletion portal and how does it change things?

A: As of June 2026, California launched a centralized portal that lets residents submit a single deletion request to all 665+ data brokers registered in the state. Services like CyberForget integrate with this portal automatically, submitting requests on your behalf and tracking compliance.

Q: Which service has the best cancellation policy?

A: All four services offer free cancellation. DeleteMe and Incogni cancel immediately with no refund for the current billing period. Optery and CyberForget offer pro-rated refunds within the first 30 days.

Q: How does CyberForget's AI scanning work differently?

A: Traditional services scan known data broker sites one-by-one, checking for your name. CyberForget cross-references 30+ data sources — including public records databases, marketing data aggregators, and data resale marketplaces — to find listings that other services miss. The AI analyzes patterns in how brokers share data, identifying new listings even when they appear under slightly different name variations or address formats.

Bottom Line: Take Action Today

Every day your personal information stays on data broker sites, it's being sold, shared, and spread further across the internet. The cost of inaction — identity theft, targeted scams, privacy violations — far exceeds the cost of any data removal service.

| Service | Annual Cost | Sites | Auto Re-Removal | Best For | |---------|------------|-------|-----------------|----------| | DeleteMe | $129 | ~70 | No | Brand trust | | Incogni | $83.88 | ~180 | No | Budget | | Optery | $149 | ~230 | No | Transparency | | CyberForget | $99 | 200+ | Yes | Best overall |

Ready to take control of your privacy? Start with CyberForget and get your personal information removed from 200+ data broker sites — with automatic re-removal and 24/7 monitoring. Your data doesn't have to be for sale.

*This comparison was last updated on June 17, 2026. Pricing and features may change. All information is accurate as of publication date.*

Take Control of Your Data

Ready to remove your personal information from data broker sites? CyberForget automates the entire process.

Start Free Scan →

← Browse All Blog Posts

CyberForget — Automate data broker removal and protect your privacy.